To answer the question, Who is the most over rated Quaterback in the NFL? "Eli Manning is the most over rated Quaterback in the NFL. Now you might think am being to hard on Manning.
Am not! The NFL, the fans, the media, and the press and the New York is being to hard on Manning. Eli, is playing well for only being in the league for afew years, however, he cannot win the big game yet. But in his defenence. Look at his father, and his brother. Eli, will always be in there shodow. That has to be hard, playing the postion as your father, and Superbowl champion brother.
Now all the eyes is on young Eli, what can he do. Man give the kid a brake. Now with all that stress on Eli, to bring the Giants to Championship glory again. That is pressure.
And that is why he is over rated. Eli cannot do it, atleast not yet. Not the Giants, maybe another team. Where he would not have to be the Super starr. Nuff Said, Good Luck Eli you are going to need it.